Start with the claim on the package
The FTC Green Guides say marketers should not misrepresent that a product or package is compostable. They also expect claims to be supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence.
For pet product sellers, that means the words compostable, biodegradable, plant-based, and eco should not be treated as decoration. The claim needs paperwork behind it
California deserves separate review
California packaging rules keep moving toward extended producer responsibility and stronger packaging accountability, CalRecycle describes SB 54 as an EPR program for packaging and single-use plastic food service ware across sectors
If you sell into California, review packaging claims, recyclable or compostable language, producer responsibility duties, and marketplace requirements before printing final packaging
State bag bans do not all work the same way
Many US plastic bag laws focus on checkout carryout bags, not every pet waste bag or refill roll, Still, a retailer may apply stricter internal rules when it reviews suppliers
Before you sell nationally, check the target states, retailer requirements, Amazon listing language, and certification files. Do not assume one label works everywhere
BPI is often the safest starting point for North America
BPI says certified products meet ASTM compostability standards and must meet program eligibility criteria, North American buyers often use BPI as a quick screen for compostable packaging claims
A BPI file does not remove the need to check certificate scope, expiration, product match, and artwork wording
Buyer checklist before launch
Ask your supplier for the certificate PDF, certificate number, holder name, product scope, material composition, bag thickness, retail artwork wording, and latest pack photos
For private label, finish compliance review before you print cartons, retail boxes, Amazon images, or claim-heavy inserts
BioPawPet can share available documents during sample review so buyers can check claims before ordering
Official sources checked
This guide uses FTC Green Guides, eCFR compostable claim language, CalRecycle SB 54 information, and BPI certification information as public reference points. It is not legal advice
